Monitoring options compared
Medical alarms, GPS trackers, passive sensors, and DIY smart home setups: what each is good at, what they miss, and how to choose.
There is no single best option. The right choice depends on your parent's mobility, cognition, willingness to wear a device, and what gives your family peace of mind. Some households combine options, and for many a regular phone call or visit is the most important check-in of all.
Disclosure: the small New Zealand business behind forwhen.nz also makes Haile, a tablet for older parents to video-call family, with an optional safety check-in. It is not yet available. This page describes categories, not products, and doesn't recommend one.
At a glance
| System | How it works | Cost |
|---|---|---|
| Medical alarm | Wearable button → 24/7 response centre | About $16 to $19/week in-home, $26 to $29/week anywhere (accredited suppliers) |
| GPS tracker | Wearable device → location tracking, fall detection | Device plus subscription; varies by provider |
| Passive sensor monitoring | Sensors → activity patterns → family alerts | Hardware plus subscription; varies by provider |
| DIY smart home | Self-configured sensors (Home Assistant, etc.) | Hardware, plus your time |
Medical alarms
Best for
- People who are mobile and cognitively sharp but at risk of falls
- Situations where a 24/7 professional response is important
- People who will actually wear and press the button
Limitations
- A standard pendant relies on the person pressing the button. If they're confused, or don't want to "bother anyone", it may not get used. Automatic fall-detection pendants are available as an add-on at extra cost (Work and Income's help doesn't cover the add-on). Like any fall detection, they can give false alarms and miss some falls.
- Doesn't detect gradual decline; only responds to acute events
- Some people stop wearing the pendant, or take it off in the shower
- Ongoing weekly cost adds up (roughly $850 to $1,000 a year for an in-home alarm). Work and Income may help through a Disability Allowance if a doctor confirms the need and the alarm comes from an accredited supplier.
GPS trackers / wearables
GPS trackers and wearables (GPS watches and trackers with location and fall detection) are available from medical alarm and GPS device providers.
Best for
- People who wander or get lost (early dementia)
- Active people who leave the house regularly
- Families who want location tracking
Limitations
- Must be worn and charged every day
- Automatic fall detection can give false alarms, and can miss a fall
- Location tracking can feel invasive; talk it through with your parent first
- Ongoing subscription cost; ask for the total cost over a year
Passive sensor monitoring
Best for
- Noticing gradual changes in routine, not just emergencies
- People who won't wear a pendant or charge a device
- Parents who don't want cameras (most systems use none)
How it typically works
- Motion, door, and appliance sensors placed around the home
- The system learns daily patterns: when they get up, move around, use the kitchen
- Family is alerted if something is unusual: no activity by 10am, front door not opened all day, overnight bathroom visits increasing
- Some systems include an SOS button or optional camera with privacy mode
Limitations
- No 24/7 response centre: alerts go to family members, not professionals, so you are the responder
- Possible false reassurance if a sensor misses an event
- It still records your parent's daily life; they should know about it and agree to it. If your parent can no longer decide this for themselves, talk it through with whoever holds their personal care and welfare EPA (or their welfare guardian): see legal matters. Keep any camera out of bedrooms and bathrooms.
- Hardware up-front cost plus a subscription; ask for the total cost over a year
- Requires WiFi and a power point
- Family members need to be willing to respond to alerts
DIY smart home
Best for
- Technically capable family members who are happy to set it up and look after it
- Highly customised setups
Limitations
- Significant setup and maintenance time, plus the hardware cost
- No built-in pattern analysis unless you set it up
- Reliability depends on how well it's set up and maintained
- When you go on holiday, who maintains it?
Which is right for your family?
| If your situation is... | Consider |
|---|---|
| Active parent, fall risk, cognitively sharp | Medical alarm |
| Early dementia, wandering risk | GPS tracker |
| Living alone, you want to notice changes in routine | Passive sensor monitoring, or a regular check-in call |
| High care needs, can't be left alone safely | Home care and respite: see government support |
| Needs constant supervision | Rest home may be the right choice: see costs |
These aren't mutually exclusive, and none replaces people. Whatever you choose, involve your parent in the decision. Their GP or an occupational therapist can help you work out what makes sense for their situation.
Sources
Medical alarm prices, accredited suppliers and help with the cost: Work and Income (weekly prices as listed in November 2026; some change on 1 December 2026). Fall detectors as an add-on not covered by that help, from the same page.
The information on this page is general in nature and does not constitute legal, financial, or medical advice. For advice specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional, and check important details with the organisation concerned before you act.
Dollar figures and entitlements change periodically. We link to authoritative sources where possible. Last reviewed: November 2026.